Refighting the Vietnam War

A bitter struggle has developed over the Pentagon’s project to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the Vietnam War.
The retirement May 5th of Army Lt. Gen. [Rtd.] Claude “Mick” Kicklighter who has headed the project for nearly four years is being viewed as a victory for the opponents of the war. Kicklighter with almost 60 years of service to the United States, including 34 years in uniform, was seen as an advocate of a broad representation including those now fighting for a “revisionist” narrative with new information of what happened in Indochina.
Allied on one side are former – and in some cases continuing – “activists”, mostly from the left — who saw the war as not only a mistaken strategic enterprise but an evil one. On the other are a minority of academics and a new veterans’ organization, Vietnam Veterans for Factual History, who seek to revise not only the conventional line in published histories but a general public concept of the origins of the war, how it was fought and its eventual conclusion.
In its first public event in early July, the veterans group stated their basic contention:

Today, politicians and pundits invoke the need to remember the “lessons of Vietnam,” but we
are unlikely to understand those “lessons” unless we establish what actually happened. Some say the
war was “unwinnable,” while others argue the other side was on the ropes by the early 1970s, until
Congress threw in the towel by outlawing the use of appropriated funds for U.S. combat operations
anywhere in Indochina. New information has emerged since the end of the war, and we believe the time has come to revisit the old debates

They hope to demonstrate the naiveté and often pro-Communist sympathies of war critics who falsely predicted “no blood bath” with a Communist victory. In fact, hundreds of thousands of South Vietnamese were not only imprisoned in “reeducation camps” but vast numbers disappeared there without ceremony, still unacknowledged by Hanoi’s Communist regime, nor by its apologists in the U.S.
The spectacle of “the boat people” – uncounted thousands died in unseaworthy ships when they chose to flee rather than live under a Communist regime – is only a faint memory for most Americans today. Of course, there were the lucky 1.5 million refugees who reached the U.S. [and the 300,000 in France and 100,000 in Australia], many after months and years in wretched refugee camps.
But today Vietnam, despite its efforts to emulate China [and now its competitor] in securing foreign investment against a handicap of universal corruption and incompetent one-party rule, remains an oppressive Communist state with recent new waves of suppression against brave political opponents and the religious..
The original intent of the Congress with $65 million was to create a website portraying the war as one of “valor” and “honor”. Kicklighter had promised that the official commemoration would include “educational materials, a Pentagon exhibit, traveling exhibits, symposiums, oral history projects, and much more.” It would have reopened a long required debate with vast new information.
But after coming under attack by Tom Hayden, a notorious opponent of the war, and a new group, the Vietnam Peace Commemoration Committee, Klinglighter abandoned the outreach program. And with his departure, it looks like the whole celebration is taking on a mournful victimization hue if not the color of the war’s opponents rather than a more balanced picture.
It will be a new tragedy if the Pentagon program becomes just another addition to the false narrative which is being fed to Americans, in their media when the subject comes up at all, and by the leftwing academic community which dominates our higher institutions today.
Is there someone in Congress who is going to bring its program back to its initial concepts?


4 responses to “Refighting the Vietnam War

  1. They feel guilty so they keep on with their efforts to rationalize their behavior.

  2. Sol, why did Mick throw in the towel? Surely a little criticism should have bounced off his thick hide. Charles Date: Mon, 1 Jun 2015 18:12:38 +0000 To:

  3. McNamara was a bean counter. He ordered the US to not leave the proper amount of ammo for the south when the US moved out. Well, it is my belief that the pundits in DC all went to the same bean counting school the Robert McNamara went to. We also did it to the muhijadeen in Afghan province during the soviet uprising. Now we are not arming the Kurds. Viet Nam sucked. No one knew why we were there. Total cluster ____The Phoenix program spilt some blood and no one went to trial and we created a great clandestine operation. Good for us. We have not won a war since WWII.
    When you se a Viet Nam Vet. Please thank him or her. They did what they were suppose to do and did it well. The beancounters counted beans in DC.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s